| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Altoona Rail Kings | Altoona, Pennsylvania | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Anderson Lawmen | Anderson, Indiana | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Clarksville Coyotes | Clarksville, Tennessee | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Columbia Mules | Columbia, Tennessee | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Cook County Cheetahs | Midlothian, Illinois | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Dubois County Dragons | Huntingburg, Indiana | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Huntington Rail Kings | Huntington, West Virginia | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Lafayette Leopards | Lafayette, Indiana | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Tennessee Tomahawks | Winchester, Tennessee | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Tupelo Tornado | Booneville, Mississippi | Heartland League | professional | defunct |
| Will County Cheetahs | Romeoville, Illinois | Heartland League | professional | defunct |