| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Akron Rubbermen | Akron, Ohio | Buckeye League | professional | defunct |
| Canton Giants | Canton, Ohio | Buckeye League | professional | defunct |
| Findlay Finns | FINDLAY, Ohio | Buckeye League | professional | defunct |
| Lima Boosters | Lima, Ohio | Buckeye League | professional | defunct |
| Marion Senators | Marion, Ohio | Buckeye League | professional | defunct |
| Newark New Socks | Newark, Ohio | Buckeye League | professional | defunct |