| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Auburn Cayuras | Auburn, New York | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Auburn Falcons | Auburn, New York | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Cornwall Canadians | Cornwall, Ontario | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Geneva Red Birds | Geneva, New York | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Geneva Robins | Geneva, New York | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Granby Red Sox | Granby, Quebec | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Kingston Ponies | Kingston, Ontario | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Mount Clemens Bathers | Mount Clemens, Michigan | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Ogdensburg Maples | Ogdensburg, New York | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Ottawa Nationals | Ottawa, Ontario | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Ottawa Senators | Ottawa, Ontario | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Pontiac Indians | Pontiac, Michigan | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Port Huron Independents | Port Huron, Michigan | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Sherbrooke Canadians | Sherbrooke, Quebec | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Watertown Athletics | Watertown, New York | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Windsor | Windsor, Ontario | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Wyandotte Alkalis | Wyandotte, Michigan | Border League | professional | defunct |
| Ypsilanti | Ypsilanti, Michigan | Border League | professional | defunct |