| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pittsburgh Stogies | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | Union Association | professional | defunct |
| Wheeling Stogies | Wheeling, West Virginia | Western Association | professional | defunct |
| Wheeling Stogies | Wheeling, West Virginia | Middle Atlantic League | professional | defunct |
| Wheeling Stogies | Wheeling, West Virginia | Central League | professional | defunct |
| Wheeling Stogies | Wheeling, West Virginia | Inter-State League | professional | defunct |