| Team name | Location | League | Level | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appleton Papermakers | Appleton, Wisconsin | Wisconsin-Illinois League | professional | defunct |
| Appleton Papermakers | Appleton, Wisconsin | Wisconsin State League | professional | defunct |
| Camas Papermakers | Camas, Washington | high school | active | |
| Covington Papermakers | Covington, Virginia | Virginia Mountain League | professional | defunct |
| Holyoke Papermakers | Holyoke, Massachusetts | Eastern Association | professional | defunct |
| Kimberly Papermakers | Kimberly, Wisconsin | high school | active | |
| Nekoosa Papermakers | Nekoosa, Wisconsin | high school | active | |
| Panama City Papermakers | Panama City, Florida | Alabama-Florida League | professional | defunct |